Physiological Characteristics Associated with W′ and W′bal Used During Intermittent Exercise Task to Failure

Authors

  • Alex Welburn Loughborough University
  • Stephen Bailey
  • Charles Pugh
  • Richard Ferguson

Keywords:

Critical Power, W', W'bal

Abstract

The critical power (CP) and W′ concept has become more integrated within applied cycling performance assessment. Both parameters can be tested for in the laboratory and field and have thus become a useful tool for coaches and athletes. The development o­­­­­f the Wbal concept allows us to mathematically model the depletion and recovery of W′ (Skiba et al., 2012, Skiba and Clarke, 2021). When exercising above CP, there is a proposed linear utilisation of W′. When exercising below CP, W′ is reconstituted (W′rec). When W′ has been fully utilised and Wbal (the balance between utilisation and reconstitution) reaches 0, it is assumed exhaustion will occur.

Despite the attention given to the underpinning physiological determinants of CP which are well established (Poole et al., 2016; Mitchell et al., 2018 and Chorley et al., 2020) the physiological determinants of W′ are not as well understood. W′ correlates with muscle volume in elite track cyclists (Kordi et al., 2021) yet there are no correlations with the muscle fibre composition (Vanhatalo et al., 2016; Mitchell et al., 2018), muscle capillarity (Mitchell et al., 2018) or mitochondrial content and function (Rogers, Ferguson et al., unpublished). It has, however, been suggested that so-called muscle typology influences W′rec following high intensity exercise (Lievens et al., 2020). Furthermore W′rec differs between intensity domains (Lievens et al., 2021) with Caen et al. (2021) concluding that W′rec following exhaustion is based on parameters of aerobic fitness due to the faster onset of V̇O2 kinetics, and thus W′rec has been demonstrated to follow a two-phased exponential time course. Despite this, more work is needed to understand the factors influencing W′ and W′rec so we can have greater confidence in its use as a performance and training tool.

As part of a wider PhD research project the associations between physiological performance characteristics, W′ and W′rec were examined. The initial aim of the study was to assess the relationship between physiological performance characteristics and W′. The second aim was to then determine which characteristics were associated with the total amount of work done above CP (W′total) during three different intermittent exercise protocols. Finally, W′rec parameters were modelled, using different Tau calculations to assess which model would predict a Wbal of 0 at exhaustion.

Thirteen endurance trained cyclists (10 males, 3 females; age: 23[8] y, height; 177 [7] cm, body mass; 69.2 [8.3] kg, V̇O2max; 54.3 [11.6] mL·min-1·kg-1, MAP; 371 [70] W, PMAX 1214 [307] W, CP; 270 [49] W, W′ 20.5 [6.2] kJ, mean [SD]) were recruited for this laboratory-based investigation. Participants attended the laboratory on seven separate occasions for the determination of V̇O2max and maximal aerobic power (MAP), lactate threshold (first LT [LT1], baseline + 0.4 mMol.L-1); second LT [LT2, fixed blood lactate concentration of 4 mMol·L-1), CP and W′ (3 and 12-minute method, Simpson and Kordi, 2017; peak lactate [Bla-]Peak and lactate clearance rate [BLa-]CLR and maximal sprint power ([Pmax; peak 1s power). All performance tests were performed on the participants own racing bicycle attached to a Wahoo Kickr with self-selected power chosen for the CP trials and main trials completed in ERG mode. Three intermittent exercise trials were also completed. Intervals were performed at a power output equivalent to the calculated 6-minute power (P6) + 50% of the difference between P6 and CP. Recovery power was 50% of LT1.  The three intermittent trial protocols involved: 3 x 60s efforts with 30s recovery proceeded by a sustained time to exhaustion (TTE); 3 x 20s with 10s recovery proceeded by a TTE; continued 20s efforts with 10s recovery until exhaustion, examining total work done above CP (W′total). Different W′bal Tau calculations were used (Skiba at al., 2012; Bartram et al., 2018 and Pugh et al., 2021 (Reg & Nat). Individualised Tau (TauINDV) using a single value to give Wbal 0 at the point of task failure were also assessed. To establish relationship between W′, W′total, and TauINDV, Person′s product-moment correlations were performed.

W′ was associated with Pmax (r=.822 p=<0.001), MAP (r=.735, P=0.004), peak [BLa-] (r=.645, p= 0.017) and V̇O2max (r=.645, p=0.026). W′total was correlated with CP·kg-1 (r=.766, p=0.002), LT1·kg-1 (r=.771, p=0.006) and PMax·kg-1 (r=.792, p=0.001). W′bal at the end of the 20:10 until exhaustion trial using the following Tau values were, Skiba, -20.3 [12.6] kJ; Bartram, 8 [3.5] kJ; Pugh Nat, -3.8 [4.3] kJ; and Pugh Reg, -2.6 [4.7]. TauINDV was correlated with CP·kg-1 (r=0.696 p=0.012), and there tended to be a correlation with LT1·kg-1 (r=0.564, p=0.056).

These data suggest that W′ has many contributing factors, with Pmax and MAP being of particular importance, likely reflecting the extent of muscle mass usually associated with high absolute power outputs.  We also demonstrate that CP, LT1 and Pmax normalised to body mass are important factors for W′total during severe intensity intermittent exercise, likely supported by associated metabolic adaptions such as large capillary networks enhancing oxygen extraction.  

Implications for applied practitioners.

Our findings confirm the possibilities to utilise the W′ and W′bal concepts within applied cycling performance assessment. We suggest Pmax should be part of the CP testing protocol.

We also propose the use of Tau as a training metric, allowing the assessment of whether an individual is improving their rate of recovery, something that has yet to be considered.  However, due to the large variances in the W′bal remaining at the point of exhaustion and task failure, as has previously been suggested, the current models need further improvement with a more standardised protocol to establish individualised Tau values. Nice!

 

Bartram, Jason C., Dominic Thewlis, David T. Martin, and Kevin I. Norton. 2018. ‘Accuracy of W’ Recovery Kinetics in High Performance Cyclists-Modeling Intermittent Work Capacity’. International Journal of Sports Physiology and Performance 13(6):724–29. doi: 10.1123/IJSPP.2017-0034.

Caen, Kevin, Gil Bourgois, Charles Dauwe, Laura Blancquaert, Kobe Vermeire, Eline Lievens, J. O. Van Dorpe, Wim Derave, Jan G. Bourgois, Lauren Pringels, and Jan Boone. 2021. ‘W ′ Recovery Kinetics after Exhaustion: A Two-Phase Exponential Process Influenced by Aerobic Fitness’. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 53(9):1911–21. doi: 10.1249/MSS.0000000000002673.

Chorley, Alan, and Kevin L. Lamb. 2020. ‘The Application of Critical Power, The Work Capacity above Critical Power (W´), and Its Reconstitution: A Narrative Review of Current Evidence and Implications for Cycling Training Prescription’. Sports 8(9). doi: 10.3390/sports8090123.

Kordi, Mehdi, Campbell Menzies, and Len Parker Simpson. 2018. ‘Relationship between Power–Duration Parameters and Mechanical and Anthropometric Properties of the Thigh in Elite Cyclists’. European Journal of Applied Physiology 118(3):637–45. doi: 10.1007/s00421-018-3807-1.

Lievens, Eline, Malgorzata Klass, Tine Bex, and Wim Derave. 2020. ‘Muscle Fiber Typology Substantially Influences Time to Recover from High-intensity Exercise’. Journal of Applied Physiology 128(3):648–59. doi: 10.1152/japplphysiol.00636.2019.

Lievens, Maarten, Kevin Caen, Jan A. N. G. Bourgois, Kobe Vermeire, and J. A. N. Boone. 2021. ‘W ′ Reconstitution Accelerates More with Decreasing Intensity in the Heavy- versus the Moderate-Intensity Domain’. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 53(6):1276–84. doi: 10.1249/MSS.0000000000002574.

Mitchell, Emma A., Neil R. W. Martin, Stephen J. Bailey, and Richard A. Ferguson. 2018. ‘Critical Power Is Positively Related to Skeletal Muscle Capillarity and Type i Muscle Fibers in Endurance-Trained Individuals’. Journal of Applied Physiology 125(3):737–45. doi: 10.1152/japplphysiol.01126.2017.

Poole, David C., Mark Burnley, Anni Vanhatalo, Harry B. Rossiter, and Andrew M. Jones. 2016. ‘Critical Power: An Important Fatigue Threshold in Exercise Physiology’. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 48(11):2320–34. doi: 10.1249/MSS.0000000000000939.

Pugh, Charles F., C. Martyn Beaven, Richard A. Ferguson, Matthew W. Driller, Craig D. Palmer, and Carl D. Paton. 2022. ‘Critical Power, Work Capacity, and Recovery Characteristics of Team-Pursuit Cyclists’. International Journal of Sports Physiology and Performance 17(11):1606–13. doi: 10.1123/ijspp.2021-0478.

Simpson, Len Parker, and Mehdi Kordi. 2017. ‘Comparison of Critical Power and W′ Derived from 2 or 3 Maximal Tests’. International Journal of Sports Physiology and Performance 12(6):825–30. doi: 10.1123/ijspp.2016-0371.

Skiba, Philip F., Weerapong Chidnok, Anni Vanhatalo, and Andrew M. Jones. 2012. ‘Modelling the Expenditure and Reconstitution of Work Capacity above Critical Power’. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 44(8):1526–32. doi: 10.1249/MSS.0b013e3182517a80.

Skiba, Philip F., and David C. Clarke. 2021. ‘The W′ Balance Model: Mathematical and Methodological Considerations’. International Journal of Sports Physiology and Performance 16(11):1561–72.

 

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Downloads

Published

2023-10-23

How to Cite

Welburn, A., Bailey, S., Pugh, C., & Ferguson , R. (2023). Physiological Characteristics Associated with W′ and W′bal Used During Intermittent Exercise Task to Failure . Journal of Science and Cycling, 12(2), 69-71. https://www.jsc-journal.com/index.php/JSC/article/view/804

Most read articles by the same author(s)